Tuesday, October 30, 2007

Ethical Economics

So just in this last week a sweatshop in India was discovered. According to various reports there were 14 pre-teen children working up to 16 hours a day, being beaten with rubber tubes if they misbehaved, crouching on their haunches all day because they didn't have chairs or benches to work on, the lucky ones were paid $0.12 per day; the unlucky were paid nothing. One report says that the hallways of the workplace were filled with human feces from an overflowing toilet (Here I've googled "Gap, Sweatshop" for you in google news).



The guilty employer this time around: GAP.


Now, I'm not big on boycotts and picketing and all that kind of stuff. I think that it's largely a waste of time and gives the wrong kind of publicity. However, the "Fair Trade" movement is something that I can get behind. The idea behind fair trade is that we as North Americans, the richest people in the world, should not be taking advantage of the third world nations by using them to increase our wealth.



Really, it shouldn't be a bad thing that the Gap has a workshop in India. In fact, it could be a great thing for the Gap to do... if they treated their workers humanely and paid them a good wage. If they did that they could actually be making a difference in the third world by helping to stimulate their economy and supporting local families and neighbourhoods.



Unfortunately, this is not the case.



The fair trade movement is all about making sure that workers all around the world are being paid an honest wage for an honest day's work. The easiest way to do this is to find brands that are "fair trade certified" and to create a demand for these products by buying them and excluding brands that aren't certified. By this method we can, bit by bit, make a difference in the third world economies. Look for this logo on your products.

Please check out this website: Fair Trade Concepts. A christian guy named Stacey Toewes runs this site. I've heard him speak on this topic a number of times.

Remember Psalm 82:3-43

"Defend the cause of the weak and fatherless;

maintain the rights of the poor and oppressed.

Rescue the weak and needy;

deliver them from the hand of the wicked."

So,

How can we as Christians become "ethically responsible consumers"?

Should big issues like this be dealt with by the church or by governments?

Are there two sides to the story?

3 comments:

Janelle said...

there are not two sides to a story where people are being abused like this - it doesn't matter if it's an American store, or a local Indian store. it's horrible.
will i stop shopping at the Gap? i'll think twice, that's for sure.
IS the government going to do anything about it? they better. and it better make bigger news than it has. the fact that i havn't heard about this yet, and it's not on CNN or something like that just speaks to how much society actually cares.

Timothy Braun said...

UPDATE:
I've learned that I've blended TWO separate incidents together.

In the last week there were TWO sweatshops (within a couple of blocks of one another) raided in New Dehli.

The GAP one was paying their children (12 cents) while the other independent clothing manufacturer was not. The children actually had to sleep on the floor and couldn't go home... if they even have homes.

I don't want to be a source of misinformation so I thought I should clear that up...

Juanita said...

Three cheers for Fair Trade!!!
Does this mean that Kaleb can't wear that really cute outfit he got from The Gap? It was made in China, does that make a difference? Something tells me it's the same story, we just may never hear it.
Tragic.